Paul Skenes, Livvy Dunne, and the Ghosts of Hobby Past
Title: Paul Skenes, Livvy Dunne, and the Ghosts of Hobby Past Paul Skenes is a highly anticipated rookie pitcher, noted for his exceptional talent and the hype surrounding him in the baseball card collecting community. He was the first overall pick in the amateur draft and has made an impressive start to his professional career, achieving a 5-0 record and a 1.72 ERA through his first five starts. Skenes' physical stature, standing 6'7" and weighing over 210 pounds, contributes to his dominant presence on the mound. The article draws a comparison between Skenes and Ben McDonald, a former rookie pitcher who, despite initial hype and a respectable career, is often considered a bust in the hobby. McDonaldâs career statistics included a 78-70 record and 20.8 WAR, but his cards are now less valued among collectors, representing a cautionary tale for Skenes. Historical context is provided, highlighting that only 24 pitchers have had an ERA below 2.50 in their rookie year over the last 125 years, with both Skenes and McDonald on that list. Other notable pitchers with similar rookie success include Steve Rogers, Mark Fidrych, and Fernando Valenzuela, none of whom are in the Hall of Fame. The document emphasizes that while Skenes has had a remarkable start, he must continue to excel to maintain the value of his baseball cards in the future. There is a mention of the "ghosts of Hobby past," indicating that past failures of hyped players can haunt current prospects like Skenes. The overarching message is that Skenes has the potential to break records and succeed, but the pressure and history of past rookie failures loom over his promising career.
Original Article: https://www.si.com/collectibles/inside-the-hobby/paul-skenes-livvy-dunne-and-the-ghosts-of-hobby-past
Original Article Author: Jason Schwartz
